I have two friends with young daughters (who don't know each other) who are both having difficulty adjusting to their first experience of having a male teacher.
One child is 3 years old and attends a variety of children's programs in which she interacts with both male and female role models. She has recently started to complain about any program that she attends that has a male teacher. Her complaining hasn't gotten worse over time and doesn't seem to involve a particular teacher or activity, so her mom and I think this is just a phase she's going through.
The other child is starting first grade and her classroom teacher is a man. She has never had a male teacher before and has made some unusual comments about the teacher to her father (nothing to indicate any sort of abuse, just odd stuff). She has also been complaining of frequent stomach aches since school began earlier this week. I'm more concerned about this child because of the physical symptoms and the fact that she will spend the entire school year with this teacher. This child's father intends to speak with the teacher in a non-confrontational manner to discuss strategies for helping his daughter adjust to this situation. Since I recall having a strained relationship with my first male teacher (in 4th grade), despite being the "teacher's pet," I don't think this reaction to a first male teacher is extremely unusual. Have you experienced this as a male teacher? Do you have any advice?
--Melinda
When I was in 5th grade
I entered 5th grade, back in 1989, when I had my first male teacher. I was scared all summer when I found out I was in "his" class. I heard all the horror stories "he's mean, he yells, he throws desks" I heard him yell myself and saw him pick up a kid who had kicked him and spit in his face-- so yeah I was scared and nervous. But once school started-- and the relationship began between teacher and student-- I had So much FUN... it was amazing he was one of the best teachers I had at that school. And I understood why he yelled or "throw desks"... kids don't always pay attention and can be very fresh. He used his masculinity as a management tool. When a kid would flip him off or swear at him, he'd raise his off. We knew what our place was but also knew how much fun he was!! My love for science grew in his class and I enjoyed his sense of humor!
I think it's natural for us to be scared/nervous of things unknown especially when we're told "horror stories" or hear things like "male teacher arrested for viewing porn in his classroom" With the media's negative view of teachers (both men and women) it's not surprising that children are scared. We (as educators and parents) need to show both sides of the story and not let one side leave a bad impression. I hope my own story helps!