Male elementary teachers are lauded by educators

by Cathy Spaulding - Muskokee, OK - Staff Writer

Preston Rogers' fifth-grade students weren't playing the board games they had on their desks Thursday morning -- they were designing them.

"I want them to be able to give instructions without them being there," Rogers said as each student wrote down rules to the different games.

Now in his second year at Grant Foreman Elementary School, Rogers seeks to do more than instruct students on writing instructions. He said, "The most important thing for me is to be a positive role model for the kids, to influence the kids in a positive way."

Other male teachers across the Muskogee area report having that same goal -- to be a positive male influence.

However, male teachers continue to make up a tiny minority of elementary-level educators. And it seems that as the grade level drops, so does the percentage of male teachers.

The organization MenTeach, a Minnesota organization dedicated to increasing the number of males working with young children, posted a survey on its Web site showing that males constitute less than 20 percent of America's 2.9 million elementary and middle school teachers. The 2008 survey, based on source data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, showed even more drastic differences among different grade levels:

* 44 percent of America's 1.2 million secondary school teachers.

* 18.8 percent of America's 2.9 million elementary and middle school teachers.

* 2.4 percent of America's 685,000 pre-kindergarten and kindergarten teachers.

At Northeastern State University, males made up 18 percent of students going into all levels of teaching, less than 1 percent of those going into elementary teaching and none going into early childhood, according to Dr. Kay Grant, dean of the NSU College of Education.

Schools in Muskogee, Wagoner, Fort Gibson and Tahlequah showed similar statistics.

A search of Web sites for the 11 elementary schools in Muskogee Public Schools showed 17 male teachers, not including four teaching music, four teaching physical education, four teaching fifth and sixth grades, three fourth-grade teachers and one science specialist, Taf Morphis, at Ben Franklin Science Academy.

Only Tony Goetz Elementary showed having a teacher for primary grades: Second-grade teacher Jimmy Monroe.

No male teachers were listed at the Early Childhood Center.

Fort Gibson has three male teachers at its Intermediate Elementary, none at the Early Learning Center. Hilldale has one male teacher at the Upper Elementary, which serves grades three through five, none at its lower elementary.

Tahlequah Public Schools has five male teachers in grades pre-kindergarten through fifth. They include three physical education teachers, a fourth-grade teacher and a third-grade teacher.

At Wagoner, Jack Lee teaches pre-kindergarten at Lincoln Elementary.

Kathy Adams, lead teacher and building administrator at Lincoln called Lee "an amazing teacher."

"He looks at each child at their level," she said. "He's creative, talented and very caring."

Adams said Lee plays an important role as a positive role model for the young children.

"Many don't have fathers at home," she said. "They see the positive and good things that daddies can do."

Sandy Brewer, incoming principal at St. Joseph Catholic School, agrees with the assessment. The school has two male teachers in the fifth and sixth grades.

"They're wonderful role models for the boys," Brewer said. "The boys need to see more than women helping the students."

However, males going into elementary or early childhood education face a stigma, Grant said.

"We would certainly like to have more male teachers as far as positive role models are concerned, but there are a number of societal factors that keep them from doing it," she said.

For example, many men might seek higher salaries in other careers, she said.

Another stigma deals with unfair suspicion of inappropriate behavior with young children, Grant said.

"Unfortunately, males who go into this area have to justify why they would want to teach that age of childhood," she said.

Though in short supply, male teachers are in high demand, Grant observed. "The ones that are in first, second or third grades are snatched up pretty quickly."

Monroe said he had not planned to teach second grade when he interviewed at Tony Goetz Elementary. He said he had been hired to teach fifth grade.

"Then the principal said, 'Would you mind teaching second grade,'" he said. "You have to be willing to be flexible."

Rogers, a 2000 Muskogee High School graduate, said he originally was hired to teach fourth grade last school year, then went to fifth grade this school year.

Fifth-grader Nina King said Rogers helped her learn to write paragraphs and poetry.

Rogers said he realizes he is in a unique position.

"All the ladies I've worked with have helped me grow as a teacher," he said. "And I'm friends with all the other men teachers."

May 6, 2009

Go to the website.